Don’t Break a Leg

Share this post

Many people are bowlegged. Some are knock-kneed. Only a few are truly straight-legged.

Most of the great runners are bowlegged. The running backs in football are all bowlegged. Many of the football linemen, who must squat and be forceful, are neutral to knock-kneed.

If so many great athletes have these leg angles, why are so many people recommended to have a “corrective” osteotomy: a cutting of the tibia, and occasionally the femur, to change the alignment of their legs?

Because of arthritis—and dogma. Orthopedic surgery students are taught that bad biomechanics will destroy good biology any day of the week. So if a patient complains of knee pain with bowed legs, the recommendation has often been to change the alignment of the legs and distribute more force to the center or the outside of the knee. Or if a patient has injured their weight-bearing surface articular cartilage or lost a portion of their meniscus cartilage, the leg gets cut in half, the foot pushed over to the centerline, a plate and screws applied, and six months of healing begins. Unfortunately, very few top athletes have ever returned to their previous level of play after this “corrective” procedure.

The advocates of osteotomy, which is much more common in Europe than in the US, argue that the newer plates and screws, the improved surgical techniques and the updated rehab programs have made this surgical technique safer and better. They state that the results are gratifying, with a reduction of pain. Yet the medical literature still reports a high complication rate. And if an artificial knee replacement is required at a later date, the results are compromised by the osteotomy.

What is the alternative? Almost everyone with pain in one side of the joint or the other has had a cartilage injury; they have either damaged the surface or lost the meniscus or both. My bias is to replace the missing meniscus and repair the damaged cartilage first and see if that is good enough.

It almost always is. The problem is the cartilage loss and arthritis—not the curvature of the bones. While it may be argued that changing the curvature could improve the outcome of the cartilage replacement procedures, this has not been borne out in our experience except when the curvature is extreme (greater than seven degrees from straight). Our long-term data, and the data of other cartilage replacement centers, bear out this conclusion.

But the cartilage loss must be treated promptly. Otherwise, the legs gradually collapse into being more bowed or knock-kneed. The surfaces on both the tibia and the femur wear off, eventually becoming bone-on-bone. At this point, either the joint must be reopened with an osteotomy and the cartilage replaced or a partial knee replacement performed. With the introduction of the surgical robot, this partial resurfacing is now becoming more common.

As with so many problems in medicine, identifying the problem—in this case, cartilage loss—and solving it directly is safer and more effective than treating the symptoms. It’s odd that we keep re-learning the same lesson.

 

 

Posted by Kevin R. Stone, M.D on August 8th, 2016
Share this post
Fix a meniscus to avoid arthritis
A recent study suggested that meniscus surgery doesn't help. Studies can be misleading. Even small losses of meniscus tissue lead to big changes in force concentration on the tibia (shin bone) and eventually arthritis.
How to Run Without Pain
Pain and running: Do they have to go together? Not for everybody. Here, in a nutshell, are my 10 best tips for diminishing pain while running:
Building SuperHumans
It is a heady time in the world of human empowerment. We are seeing technologies that can alter our genetic code, augment our brainpower, enhance our physique, and extend our lives.
July 14th, 2015
In light of Wes Matthews and other NBA athletes suffering Achilles ruptures, Dr. Stone speaks to Mavs Moneyball, a...
July 11th, 2018
Dr. Stone gives the nation running tips on how to avoid pain while protecting your joints.
April 27th, 2016
Dr Stone talking about Steph Curry's injury and the Warrior's season.

Kevin R. Stone · Jonathan R. Pelsis · Scott T. Surrette · Ann W. Walgenbach · Thomas J. Turek 

Stone, K.R., A. Freyer, T. Turek, A.W. Walgenbach, S. Wadhwa, and J. Crues. 2007.